Tom Scottt Law Indy

Bankruptcy Attorneys in Indianapolis Since 1980

Questions About Bankruptcy

COVID-19 Update: How Will the CARES Act Affect a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 Bankruptcy?

by

CARES Act Will Temporarily Change Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Rules

The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act) legislation being developed by Congress, to provide emergency assistance and health care response for individuals, families, and businesses affected by the 2020 coronavirus pandemic, also provides temporary changes to Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 of the United States Bankruptcy Code. The changes are as follows:

  • For purposes of calculating a debtor’s income to determine his or her eligibility for Chapter 7 and Chapter 13, coronavirus-related payments from the federal government are excluded from the analysis.
     
  • Similarly, coronavirus-related payments are not considered in determining a debtor’s disposable income for a Chapter 13 plan of reorganization.
     
  • Lastly, the CARES Act allows Chapter 13 debtors who have already confirmed a plan to modify the plan based on a material financial hardship caused by the pandemic, including extending their payments for seven years after their initial plan payment was due.

The changes apply in pending Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 cases and will be applicable for one year from the effective date of the CARES Act.
For more information about how this affects your situation, please contact us.

U.S. Congress Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act)

  1. PDF provides a complete and accurate display of the text.
  2. Web page with links to each section of the bill’s text.

$20,000 Contempt Penalty Because Mother Hurt Father’s Credit Should Be Dischargeable In Bankruptcy

by

*Disclosure required by 11 U.S.C. § 528(a)(3): We, the law office of Tom Scott & Associates, P.C., are a debt relief agency. We help people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code.
Q: A state court judge orders the mother to pay the father $20,000.00 following a contempt hearing as a penalty for actual costs of petitioner’s attorney fee. The award is a contempt penalty following the Judge’s determination that the mother has not been paying student loans in a timely manner thus harming the father’s credit and that the mother has not complied with a parenting time order. Is that penalty dischargeable in Bankruptcy?
A: Bankruptcy Code Section 523 provides a list of debts that are not dischargeable in bankruptcy. Specifically 523(a)(7) states: A bankruptcy discharge “does not discharge an individual debtor from any debt – … (7) to the extent that such debt is for a fine, penalty, or forfeiture payable to and for the benefit of a governmental unit, and is not compensation for actual pecuniary loss…”
Under section 523(a)(7), civil contempt sanctions are generally non-dischargeable where, they are imposed to uphold the dignity and authority of the court. For example see U.S. Sprint Communications Co. v. Buscher, 89 B.R. 154, 156 (D.Kan.1988); PRP Wine Int’l, Inc. v. Allison (In re Allison), 176 B.R. 60, 63-64 (Bankr.S.D.Fla.1994). In these cases, the dischargeability of a prior fine was at issue in a subsequent bankruptcy.
A “debtor seeking to discharge a pre-petition sanction faces an uphill battle. While he has the ability under Bankruptcy Rule 4007 to seek a determination of the dischargeability of the sanction in that subsequent proceeding, the bankruptcy court will evaluate and adjudicate the prior debt’s dischargeability guided at least in part by § 523(a)(7). It is for this reason that a representative of a corporate debtor, like Mr. Hansbrough, is not free flatly to ignore the bankruptcy court’s orders, absorb any sanction the court can muster, and then simply file a personal bankruptcy petition before a different court and obtain a discharge as a matter of course.” In Re Hercules Enterprises, Inc., d/b/a JP’s Health Club, Debtor. James Hansbrough, Appellant, v. David Birdsell, Chapter 7 Trustee of Hercules Enterprises, Inc.’s Bankruptcy Estate, Appellee, 387 F.3d 1024 (9th Cir, 2004).
Accordingly, my reading of the Bankruptcy Code is that Section 523(a)(7) creates a two prong test to determine whether a civil contempt action is dischargeable in bankruptcy:
1) The debt cannot be discharged if the penalty is payable to and for the benefit of a governmental unit; AND
2) The debt cannot be discharged if the penalty is not compensation for actual pecuniary loss [a “pecuniary loss” is defined as “a loss that can be evaluated in money terms” (Black’s Law Dictionary)].

If mother files a Chapter 7 bankruptcy and receives a discharge, even if the current $20,000.00 penalty is dischargeable, the underlying order to remain current on student loans is not dischargeable. The mother should file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy to attempt a discharge of both the civil contempt penalty as well as the property settlement order.

In the facts presented, the state court order was that the money be paid directly to the father and not payable to or for the benefit of the any governmental unit. Therefore, the first prong is not met and the debt can be discharged in bankruptcy. The second prong is that the debt cannot be discharged if the debt is not compensation for actual pecuniary loss. Conversely then, the debt is dischargeable in bankruptcy if the penalty is for actual pecuniary loss. In this case, the court order does specifically state that penalty is for actual compensation so it should be dischargeable in bankruptcy.
More importantly, however, is that the divorce decree directed the mother to remain current on student loans and hold the father harmless as a co-debtor. Through issuance of this divorce decree order, the state court has created another potential debt for the mother; that is, the father can collect money for damages if the mother does not remain current on student loans. This potential debt to father will remain in effect until either the student loan is timely paid or the divorce decree order is discharged. A Chapter 7 bankruptcy will NOT discharge any debt to a former spouse that was incurred by the debtor in the course of a divorce. Therefore, if mother files a Chapter 7 bankruptcy and receives a discharge, even if the current $20,000.00 penalty is dischargeable, the underlying order to remain current on student loans is not dischargeable. Accordingly, if the mother ever falls behind on student loans in the future, the father could simply seek another post-discharge contempt order and the mother would have to appear again before an already unhappy judge. Therefore, I would recommend that the mother file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy to attempt a discharge of both the civil contempt penalty as well as the property settlement order.

Income & Assets: Basics of Bankruptcy – Chapter 13 vs. Chapter 7 – Part 1

by

In this second installment of our series “Basics of Bankruptcy,” we discuss reasons to file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy rather than the less complex Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

WHY FILE CHAPTER 13 ANYWAY?

When considering to file bankruptcy, the first decision that probably should be made is whether you should file either a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy. There are several reasons why a debtor should (or must) file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, including (but not necessarily limited to):

  1. Not eligible for a Chapter 7 discharge
  2. Above-Median debtor
  3. Debtor does not want to liquidate assets
  4. Curing a mortgage
  5. Cramming a mortgage
  6. Stripping
  7. Cramming a car
  8. Cramming other personal property
  9. Lowering interest rates on cars (and other collateral)
  10. Liquidating tax debts
  11. Protecting a co-debtor

In this post, we will look at the first three reasons above to choose Chapter 13. The remaining reasons will be covered in parts 2-4 of this series.

Not Eligible for a Chapter 7 Discharge.

Summary: A person cannot file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy within eight year of previously filing for Chapter 7 or Chapter 11, or within six years of filing for Chapter 12 or Chapter 13 protection.

Not Eligible for a Chapter 7 Discharge (opens in new window)
Click for US Code, Title 11, Chapter 7, Subchapter II, Section 727

Pursuant to US Code, Title 11, Chapter 7, Subchapter II, Section 727(a)(8)*, you (the debtor) are not eligible for a Chapter 7 discharge if you were granted a discharge in a Chapter 7 or Chapter 11 bankruptcy in a case that began within eight years before the date of the new bankruptcy filing.
Further, Section 727(a)(9) states that the debtor will not be eligible for a Chapter 7 discharge if the debtor was granted a discharge in a Chapter 12 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy filed within six years of the new filing (unless the plan payments paid 100% of allowable claims or paid 70% of such claims and the plan was proposed in good faith and was the debtor’s best effort).
Thus, an individual who received a discharge in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy six years prior would either have to wait two more years or file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

Above-Median Debtor

Summary: The court may dismiss an individual consumer debtor’s case filed under Chapter 7 if the debtor’s household income is greater than the median income for a household of the same size.
Filing Chapter 7 would create abuse.
Pursuant to Section 707(b)*, the court may dismiss an individual consumer debtor’s case filed under Chapter 7 if it finds that the granting of relief would be an abuse of the provisions of Chapter 7.

  • If the debtor’s household income is greater than the median income for a household of the same size, then the court shall presume abuse exists if current monthly income minus the means test standardized expenses leaves at least $182.50/mo (or $10,950.00 for 60 months).
  • If the net result is greater than $109.58/mo ($6,575.00 for 60 months), but less than the $182.50 figure, then there shall be a presumption of abuse if the net figure times sixty is at least 25% of the debtor’s general unsecured debts. In other words, if the debtor has incurred large amounts of debt, then the debtor may actually be more likely to get a discharge in a Chapter 7.
  • The presumption of abuse may only be rebutted by demonstrating special circumstances “such as a serious medical condition or a call or order to active duty in the Armed Forces, to the extent such special circumstances that justify additional expenses or adjustments of current monthly income for which there is no reasonable alternative” [See Section 707(b)(2)(B)(i)].

Debtor does not want to Liquidate Assets

Summary: Debtor may protect those assets that they do not want to have liquidated by filing for Chapter 13 bankruptcy protection rather than Chapter 7.
Under a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the duty of the trustee is to “collect and reduce to money, the property of the estate for which the trustee serves” [Section 704(a)*].
If, after utilizing all applicable exemptions for your client, there remains an asset that may be properly liquidated and your client desires to retain such assets, your client may protect those assets by filing for Chapter 13 bankruptcy protection.
As stated in Section 1325(a)(4)*, the court shall confirm a plan if the value of property to be distributed under the plan is not less than the amount that would be paid on such claim if the estate of the debtor were liquidated under Chapter 7 of this title.
In our next post, we will discuss mortgage curing, cramming, and stripping, methods employed to help reduce debt.

* Source: Cornell University Law School Legal Information Institute

If my home has a second mortgage, can I file bankruptcy on just one of the mortgages and still keep the house?

by

Thanks for submitting your question. You can accomplish different goals if you declare bankruptcy, so you need to consider all of the details of your lenders’ promissory notes and mortgages, along with your complete financial and credit position, to determine your best course of action.
This answer to your question does not consider your specific case, but covers the general issues involved in a situation like this. You may want to consult with a bankruptcy attorney to ensure your case is handled to meet your goals.
When you purchased your home you signed two pieces of paper with each lender – a promissory note and a mortgage.

  • The promissory note is just that — a promise that you will repay the debt.
  • The mortgage is a "lien" (or encumbrance) that provides a means for the lender to get some or all of its money back, if you do not pay on the promissory note.

When you purchased your home, you very likely made an agreement with the lender which says something like, “I agree to pay you each and every month on the promissory note and if I do not pay, then you can foreclose on my home.”
Foreclosure is the legal action of proving to a judge that you did not keep up your promise and asking permission for the court (through the local sheriff) to sell the real estate to the highest bidder at auction and “foreclose” everyone else’s interest in that real estate.
Please keep these concepts in mind as we very briefly skim the surface of bankruptcy.
There are primarily two chapters of bankruptcy that deal with consumer debts, called Chapter 7 and Chapter 13.
An individual only qualifies for a Chapter 7 if his or her income is low enough. With regard to a house with mortgages in Chapter 7, a debtor can usually do one of two things: 1) keep the home; or 2) surrender the home. If a debtor keeps the home and is current on payments, the debtor will usually “reaffirm” the debt by signing a “reaffirmation agreement.”

  • The reaffirmation agreement keeps the debtor on the hook so to speak, and requires that the debtor continue to make all payments in the normal fashion as though the bankruptcy had never occurred.
  • If the debtor does not sign a reaffirmation agreement then the personal requirement to continue to make payments in the “promissory note” will go away, but the lien rights under the mortgage do not go away. In other words:
    • If you do not sign a reaffirmation agreement and stop paying for your home, the lender can never collect any more money from you on the promissory note as that debt has been eliminated by the bankruptcy.
    • However, the lender could still foreclose on the real estate to try and get some of its money back from the sale.

So to answer your question regarding a Chapter 7 – “Presuming that you do not have significant equity in your home, you are current on your mortgages, and your income is low enough to qualify for a Chapter 7 filing, you would be able to keep your home if you would like. The law requires that we list ALL your creditors, including the first and second mortgage lenders, in the bankruptcy (whether you want to reaffirm the debt or surrender the debt).
You would need to continue making payments on both mortgages if you wanted to keep the home.”
Regarding Chapter 13 – almost any individual can file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy (with certain restrictions that your attorney should know under Section 109e). Individuals must file a Chapter 13 if their income is too high, or if they filed a Chapter 7 in the prior eight years (or a Chapter 13 in the prior 6 years).
BUT, some people file a Chapter 13 for other reasons besides the mandatory ones, including, but limited to:

  1. Saving a home that is in foreclosure
  2. Lowering payments on an auto that does not have favorable lending terms
  3. Paying back taxes without concern for future penalties or IRS levy
  4. Protecting assets from being sold in a Chapter 7
  5. Protecting co-debtors from law-suits

But there is another reason why someone MIGHT want to file a Chapter 13, and that is in limited circumstances we might be able to remove a second mortgage.

  • In a situation where the balance owed on the first mortgage is higher than the value of the home, we can try to strip off a second mortgage. The law allows it, and the only reason that I say “try” to strip off the second mortgage is that the lender may think that the value of the home is higher than we do.
  • So, if the payoff on the first mortgage is $150,000.00 and the fair market value of the home is only $100,000.00 then a Chapter 13 will allow us to strip off the second mortgage and treat it like any other unsecured creditor (like a credit card or medical bills).

In a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the law requires that you remain in Chapter 13 for 36 to 60 months, depending on your income, but when the case is complete you will only have one mortgage on your home – and yes you get to keep the home.
So, with all that being said, while we are available to answer any of your questions via phone or email, we would suggest instead that we meet in person to go over the details of such a complex issue. Feel free to send us an email or contact our office at 317-255-9915 to schedule a free consultation at one of our three convenient locations.

What is bankruptcy?

by

Bankruptcy is a court supervised proceeding which is intended to give debtors a break from creditors’ collection activities while the court tries to determine if there is any way possible to try and get some money to creditors in exchange for debts being discharged (“going away”).
You see, the goal under any chapter of bankruptcy (at least as far as Congress is concerned) is to try and generate funds to give to the creditors and in exchange for that attempt the debtor’s debts will be discharged [except for several exceptions including but not limited to certain taxes, student loans, domestic support obligations, criminal fines and restitution, and personal injury automobile accidents involving drugs or alcohol].
In most cases, creditors do not get anything at all, and that is really why you would need legal advice to help make such a determination. The two chapters of the bankruptcy code that deal with consumer debts are Chapters 7 and 13. The biggest difference between a Chapter 7 and a Chapter 13 is how the court looks for money to give to creditors.

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy

A Chapter 7 can be thought of as a “liquidation” bankruptcy. The court will value the debtor’s property and determine whether property may be liquidated and funds given to the unsecured creditors. Each state allows debtors to keep property necessary for the “fresh start.” The property that may be kept (which is exempt from liquidation) is called an exemption.
In Indiana, the major exemptions are as follows:

  1. Retirement (in a qualified retirement account) is fully exempt;
  2. Real or personal property constituting the debtor’s primary residence is exempt up to $17,600.00 in equity ($35,200.00 for a married couple);
  3. Personal property valued up to $9,350.00 is exempt ($18,700.00 for a married couple); and
  4. Intangible assets up $350.00 are exempt ($700.00 for a married couple).

While the majority of cases are “no asset” cases (meaning there is nothing to give creditors), debtors must honestly and fairly list all assets and cooperate with the court in liquidation of assets in order to receive a Chapter 7 bankruptcy discharge.
The entire Chapter 7 bankruptcy takes approximately 120 days from start to finish and is a fairly simply way to obtain a fresh start.

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

There are many reasons to file a Chapter 13, but only two reasons why a debtor would have to file Chapter 13. The first is that a debtor must file a Chapter 13 if the debtor has filed a Chapter 7 and received a discharge in the prior eight (8) years.
Secondly, a debtor must file a Chapter 13 id the debtor earns too much money and would have some “disposable income” available to pay to the court each month. In a Chapter 13 a debtor is basically saying, “I do not earn enough money to pay off all these debts, but I am working and making a good living, so I might be able to pay off some of the debt over a period of time.”
An attorney would be needed to determine whether you must be in a Chapter 13 and how much the court will require that you pay back to creditors.

Are there different types of bankruptcy?

by

There are several chapters of bankruptcy including Chapter 7, Chapter 9, Chapter 11, Chapter 12, and Chapter 13. The majority of consumer cases are either Chapter 7 or Chapter 13.
A few of our business clients must file Chapter 11 (which is a business reorganization) or Chapter 12 (which is exclusively for farmers). Chapter 9 is for governments, and you may have heard that Detroit, Michigan recently filed for Chapter 9 bankruptcy protection.
Learn more: Chapter 7 vs. Chapter 13

What is the process to file bankruptcy?

by

All you need to do is contact our office and set a free consultation with one of our experienced bankruptcy attorneys. Each of our lawyers has focused almost exclusively on the bankruptcy law for at least 15 years, and we feel confident that we will be able to answer your questions and reduce your stress.
If you decide that bankruptcy will help reduce your stress and make your life happier, then we will discuss the fees (which will depend on the complexity of your case) and go over the information that we will need to put together the bankruptcy petition that will be filed with the Federal Bankruptcy Court. We will be with you every step of the way.

How long does the bankruptcy process take?

by

In a Chapter 7 case, once the case is filed we will attend a meeting with the court approximately 30-45 days after the case is filed and the debts will be discharged approximately 60 days later. Therefore, we can expect a total period of approximately four (4) months from filing date to discharge date.
In a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, Congress requires that a plan payment continue anywhere from 36-60 months. Once the plan payments are complete, the court discharges debts approximately 60 days later. However, while you are in bankruptcy you will be protected by the stay (which prohibits creditors from collecting any debts).